Daveosaurus (southerndave) wrote,
Daveosaurus
southerndave

Dishonest advertising

Before I go any further, a reassurance to local readers: No, I'm not even considering Xtra. I've just seen their latest advertisement one (or more) too many times, asked a few quick questions and worked out that it's basically totally dishonest.

The Product: They're advertising a Super Special of 10 GB "broadband" internet per month. If it was from any provider other than Xtra or Vodaphone, it might even have been a reasonable deal. (Xtra is infamous for so-called "broadband" that's barely faster than my dial-up used to be before IHUG slowed down back when IINet owned it; and Vodaphone are so incompetent that they thought that buying IHUG of IINet would get them into the internet market without having to do any more work.)

The Advertisement: Some indeterminately aged youngster (maybe about 14 years old) is standing chest deep in a room filled with jellybeans. These jellybeans symbolise 10 GB of internet. Each one is an email, and, (here a small amount of jellybeans - maybe a small bucketful - is tipped over the boy), "that's a movie".

The Calculations: Assuming a reasonably sized room (the room in question looks a bit like a lounge), a measurement of 3m x 3.3m (10 ft x 11 ft) would be reasonable. That would make 10 m² of floor space, and, assuming for the sake of easy calculation that chest high on the youngster is 1m (3 ft 4 in), that would make 10 m³ of jellybeans symbolising 10 GB of internet. While the amount of jellybeans tipped over the youngster is difficult to tell, it looks like a small bucketful; I'll be generous and assume 0.1 m³ (about 3 ft³).

The Dishonesty: This advertisement implies that a movie downloaded off the Internet would be about 100 MB. I did a bit of asking around on IRC the other night, and people who have actually managed to download movies off the Internet have advised me of various sizes of various movies; the smallest was about 600 MB and the largest was over 1.3 GB. Assuming for the sake of this exercise that a typical movie would be 1 GB in size, this means that the Xtra advertisment is false and misleading in implying that with 10 GB of internet, one could download 100 movies; whereas in truth one could only download 10 movies.
Tags: arse end of the world, false advertising, xtra sucks
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 10 comments